apron logo

 

Our Menu & More

 

Please note a 48-72 hours advance notice is required when ordering full size & specialty cheesecakes.

What We Offer


Mini Assorted Cheesecakes

“Perfectly portioned and impossible to resist”

Single Mini Cheesecake $3.75

4 Pack $15.00 ($3.75 each)

6 Pack $22.00 ($3.75 each)

1 Dozen $40.00 ($3.33 each)

25 Pack $80.00 ($3.20 each) pre-order only, not available in store

 

START A CUSTOM Order

Cheesecake Cups

These are 5oz cheesecake cups, all vanilla bean and the flavors come from the toppings. In store 15+ flavors are available.

$6 each

 

START A CUSTOM Order

Order a Whole Cheesecake

Dreaming of the perfect cheesecake? With over 200 customizable 9″ cheesecake flavors, we’re ready to create something unforgettable just for you.

Please allow at least 72 business hours notice for all custom whole cheesecake orders.

 

6″ Cheesecake
Feeds 4–6 people • $38
Some customization are available for an additional charge

 

START A CUSTOM Order

9″ Cheesecake

Feeds approximately 10 restaurant-size slices or more with smaller portions • $65
Some customizations are available for an additional charge

 

START A CUSTOM Order

We offer over 150 flavors! Here is just a sampling of our delicious options! 

Cherry – Vanilla bean cheesecake topped with cherries & buttercream
Black Forest – Chocolate & cherry cheesecake topped with chocolate ganache & chocolate buttercream, chocolate curls and cherries
Reese’s Extreme – Peanut Bitter cheesecake topped with chocolate & peanut butter ganache, chocolate buttercream and Reese’s Cup & chocolate curls
Lemon Blueberry – Vanilla bean cheesecake with lemon and blueberry swirl, topped with a blueberry buttercream and fresh blueberries.
Blueberries-n-Cream – Vanilla bean cheesecake swirled with blueberry cheesecake, topped with a blueberry buttercream & fresh blueberries
Strawberry Crunch -Vanilla bean cheesecake swirled with strawberry cheesecake, topped with a strawberry buttercream & fresh strawberries
Raspberry White Chocolate – Vanilla bean cheesecake swirled with a raspberry puree, fresh raspberries and topped with a vanilla buttercream and fresh raspberries. 
Triple Berry – Vanilla bean cheesecake topped with fresh berries
Blackberry Lavender – Lavender cheesecake with fresh blackberries, topped with buttercream and fresh blackberries  
Oreo – vanilla bean cheesecake packed with oreos, topped with chocolate ganache, chocolate buttercream and oreos
Caramel Apple – Caramel cheesecake with apples, topped with buttercream and a caramel candy
Espresso – Chocolate espresso cheesecake topped with chocolate ganache, chocolate buttercream and an espresso truffle
Key Lime – Vanilla bean cheesecake topped with key lime and coconut cream, white buttercream, toasted coconut and a coconut truffle
Strawberry – Vanilla bean cheesecake topped with strawberry puree, strawberry slices & strawberry buttercream 
Snickers – Vanilla bean cheesecake topped with chocolate ganache, caramel, chocolate buttercream & Snickers candy bar
Buckeye – Vanilla bean cheesecake topped with chocolate & peanut butter ganache, chocolate buttercream, red and silver sprinkles and buckeyes
Reese’s Cup – Vanilla bean cheesecake topped with chocolate & peanut butter ganache, chocolate buttercream & a Reese’s Cup candy with chocolate curls 
Mini Cheesecakes

 

Whole Cheesecakes 

 

Specialty Flavors

 

Flavor of the Week

 

Special Event Catering

 

Individual Slices

 

START A CUSTOM Order
Gifts at Messy Aprons
Gifts at Messy Aprons

Small Gifts

 

Shop locally by supporting many small businesses in our gift boutique.

Looking for a Custom Cheesecake?

Ordering Information

There are several ways to place an order for store pickup. Orders may be placed online or by calling the store and speaking directly with a member of our team.

When ordering assorted mini cheesecakes, you will be able to choose from flavors currently available in store. Custom 6” and 9” cheesecakes require 48–72 business hours advance notice, as each cheesecake is handcrafted and made to order.

We also carry a daily selection of 6” cheesecakes, cheesecake slices, and cheesecake cups available while supplies last. To ensure availability for your special event or celebration, we highly recommend placing your order in advance.

Same-day orders may be available depending on size and topping requests, with turnaround times ranging from approximately 15 minutes to 2 hours.

Store Pickup Location
Strongsville • 14300 Pearl Rd.
Strongsville, OH 44136

Phone
440-879-1200

Hours
Tuesday – Friday: 11:00am – 6:00pm
Saturday: 10:00am – 3:00pm
Closed Sunday & Monday

Start a CUStom Order

Get in Touch